News

Numerous ESG measures, yet a weak EcoVadis score – where are the points lost?

The code of ethics has been completed, training sessions are in place, emissions are being measured, and sustainability requirements have been included in supplier contracts. Yet the result still falls short of expectations. The explanation often lies in the gap between a company’s actual practices and its ability to demonstrate them.

After an EcoVadis assessment, many companies ask the same question: how could we receive this result when we are doing so much? The disappointment is understandable. Within the organisation, everyone can see the training sessions, approval processes, energy efficiency investments and work with suppliers. However, the assessor can only work with what the company presents in the appropriate format and links to the relevant question.

This difference also explains the essence of the preparation process presented in the first article. Sustainability performance must be effective in practice and traceable through the documentation at the same time. If either element is missing, the result can easily be weaker than expected.

Three questions need to be answered

EcoVadis assesses the quality of a company’s sustainability management system through its commitments, actions and results. Put simply: what did the company promise, what did it do to fulfil that promise, and what changed as a result?

A code of ethics, for example, sets out the company’s expectations. Implementation is demonstrated by employees receiving training, an operational reporting channel, designated responsible persons and a procedure for handling reports. At the results level, relevant data may include the proportion of employees who completed the training, the time taken to process reports or the number of compliance checks performed.

The same logic applies to environmental protection. An emissions reduction target represents an important commitment. The related energy efficiency programme, procurement decision or technological development demonstrates implementation, while annual energy and emissions data show whether measurable results have been achieved. If the documents contain only the target, the story remains incomplete.

A document is not necessarily good evidence simply because it exists

EcoVadis expects submitted documents to demonstrate relevance, completeness, timeliness and an appropriate organisational scope. The company’s name, the date of issue or review and the purpose of the document must be clearly visible. Policies and actions are subject to an eight-year validity period, while KPI reports are valid for two years. However, a document that remains formally acceptable may already be outdated in terms of its content. Regular review is therefore part of operational maturity.

Uncertainty about scope is a common problem. A group-level policy does not in itself show whether it also applies to the local company, who implements it or what local results have been achieved. A similar issue arises when the organisational or site scope of a certificate differs from the scope of the EcoVadis assessment. In such cases, the content of the document may be sound, but it does not fully support the answer.

The 55-document limit requires careful selection

A maximum of 55 new documents can be uploaded for an assessment. This limit may tempt a company to combine as many topics as possible into a single file assembled quickly. However, EcoVadis does not accept materials created solely for the purpose of completing the questionnaire, and artificially combined evidence cannot replace genuine documents from the company’s management system.

The appropriate approach is to select relevant, robust documents that can be properly linked to several questions. A well-prepared sustainability report or annual report may provide credible evidence across several topics. The same applies to a procedure with an appropriate scope that clearly sets out responsibilities, actions and monitoring. The evidentiary value matters more than the number of files.

Sustainable procurement is a common blind spot

Companies often have detailed knowledge of the environmental and employment-related processes within their own operations, but possess less structured information about their supply chain. A supplier code of conduct is a useful foundation, but an assessable system also requires risk criteria, supplier due diligence, contractual requirements, performance assessments and corrective actions where necessary. Without the involvement of procurement, this theme can easily be reduced to a few general commitments.

There may therefore be many reasons behind lost points, including a genuine process gap, outdated documentation, limited organisational scope, missing performance data or poorly selected evidence. The purpose of preparation is to distinguish between these issues. This allows the company to identify which problems can be addressed through a quick documentation update and which require longer-term operational development.

The third article in the series begins after the assessment has been completed. We show how the findings of the scorecard can be turned into a development plan with designated responsibilities, deadlines and measurable targets.

As part of our EcoVadis assessment preparation service, we review existing company practices together with the available evidence. Once the gaps have been identified, we support the development of the documentation and related processes, as well as the professional review before submission.

Related Services

Preparation for EcoVadis Rating

Preparation for the EcoVadis assessment, including gap analysis, documentation, questionnaire support and recommendations..

Sustainability, ESG

ESG consultancy services for businesses: strategy, sustainability reporting, supplier due diligence, ESG compliance and certification with expert support.

ESG compliance and regulatory readiness

CSRD gap analysis, double materiality assessment, supply chain due diligence, EU Taxonomy compliance, ESG rating preparation.

ESG certification and assurance services

Independent ESG certification and assurance services.

Newsletter

Stay informed about the latest professional news.

Subscribe

Read our previous news and analysis.